You know me... I'll have a starter on the way in the next day or so Thanks again for your help!

 

You may want to take a close look at your battery terminals and starter connections, it sounds like you're getting a big voltage drop at the starter even though the battery is charged, clean off the corrosion that this nasty winter salt crap has caused at the battery terminals, starter connections, and frame grounding points

 

I know the battery cables at the battery are in great shape. Going to craw under this weekend and make sure everything is clean and tight if the weather will let me.