Substitute Coolant - Havoline Toxic?
#11
Uh...really?
Dexcool is still a GLYCOL based coolant.
http://www.valvoline.com/pdf/Zerex_D...l_Bulletin.pdf
Zerex has five different ethylene glycol-based formulas:
"Original" - Uses a low-silicate corrosion additive package
Dexcool - Uses Organic Acid (OAT) corrosion additives
G-05 - Uses Hybrid OAT additives that are low-silicate and phosphate-free
Asian - Uses phosphated HOAT additives that are silicate and nitrate-free
Extended Life (HD truck) - Uses OAT additives and HD corrosion inhibitors
So, back to my original question...if not the Dexcool formula, which is better or the best of the other four?
#12
#13
Thanks,
Now I am more confused about what to be running in all my vehicles.
If Dexcool is so bad for the Rovers, why is it recommended by the manufacture?
Is there any system it should be ok in, or is it bad stuff in general. My Volvo calls for it as well. I've only used the Green stuff in my Titan and have never had any problems.
I am wondering if I should just start running green stuff in everything.
Now I am more confused about what to be running in all my vehicles.
If Dexcool is so bad for the Rovers, why is it recommended by the manufacture?
Is there any system it should be ok in, or is it bad stuff in general. My Volvo calls for it as well. I've only used the Green stuff in my Titan and have never had any problems.
I am wondering if I should just start running green stuff in everything.
#14
FYI...Fleetgard is owned by Cummins...and their branded coolant is packaged by Ashland Oil/Valvoline (Zerex).
Last edited by sdhow; 02-26-2015 at 06:28 PM.
#16
As of right now, I'm leaning towards the G-05. Found an aftermarket cross-over chart published by Zerex in 2003, and it shows the Jaguars and Volvos to be switched over to their G-05. And Jag and Land Rover always followed suit...BMWs were always recommended to switch to the G-05.
Unless someone on here can convince me otherwise...
Unless someone on here can convince me otherwise...
Last edited by sdhow; 02-26-2015 at 06:26 PM.
#17
#18
My understanding is Dexcool is fine...in a perfect world. We own Rovers, so we're aware of imperfections.
Dexcool is silicate-free; silicates act as little "leak seekers" in the system (sodium silicate is also known as "liquid glass"). If you have any air in the system, from little leaks that do not seal themselves, the chemicals in Dexcool will react with the available oxygen, start a corrosive reaction inside the cooling system and propagate additional leaks.
Dexcool is silicate-free; silicates act as little "leak seekers" in the system (sodium silicate is also known as "liquid glass"). If you have any air in the system, from little leaks that do not seal themselves, the chemicals in Dexcool will react with the available oxygen, start a corrosive reaction inside the cooling system and propagate additional leaks.
#19