Intermittent noise, can't determine suspension or driveline
#1
Intermittent noise, can't determine suspension or driveline
2005 LR3 HSE 102000k miles
Looking for some advice, trying to avoid throwing parts at it. First noticed the sounds about 10 days ago and have only been able to recreate it 2 times since. The only consistent conditions are climbing a hill while turning or curving to the left. (Weight shifted to the rear and passengers side) The maddening part it that I can turn around immediately and drive the same stretch of road and can't get the noise again.
The noise is rotational, and almost sounds/feels like a u-joint or cv joint binding. Seems to come from the rear of the vehicle, but sometimes seems like coming from the center. Also sometimes get a slight "thump" in the rear when coming to and leaving a stop sign. Again, inconsistent. Comes and goes quickly.
When not showing these symptoms the truck is butter smooth at speed, no vibrations or hums. Even if I try some repeated "on and off" the gas, I can't get the thump from the rear. Trans shifts fast and smooth.
Any thoughts? Really just trying to avoid throwing parts at this.
Thanks in advance!
Looking for some advice, trying to avoid throwing parts at it. First noticed the sounds about 10 days ago and have only been able to recreate it 2 times since. The only consistent conditions are climbing a hill while turning or curving to the left. (Weight shifted to the rear and passengers side) The maddening part it that I can turn around immediately and drive the same stretch of road and can't get the noise again.
The noise is rotational, and almost sounds/feels like a u-joint or cv joint binding. Seems to come from the rear of the vehicle, but sometimes seems like coming from the center. Also sometimes get a slight "thump" in the rear when coming to and leaving a stop sign. Again, inconsistent. Comes and goes quickly.
When not showing these symptoms the truck is butter smooth at speed, no vibrations or hums. Even if I try some repeated "on and off" the gas, I can't get the thump from the rear. Trans shifts fast and smooth.
Any thoughts? Really just trying to avoid throwing parts at this.
Thanks in advance!
#3
We bought it with 86k, haven't done diffs yet. It was meticulously maintained at a rover dealership, all recommended service performed. Not sure if that includes diffs though. Just had the trans and t-case serviced, planning on diffs soon. I have the locker, can I use the royal purple on the locker? Or do I need factory fluid?
I though about the diff too, just have a hard time accepting that a diff would be intermittent and so hard to replicate. Wouldn't be the first time I was wrong though...
I though about the diff too, just have a hard time accepting that a diff would be intermittent and so hard to replicate. Wouldn't be the first time I was wrong though...
#5
#6
I can hear it humming, leaks and fluid was contaminated with water when I drained it
We put it on a lift and ran in drive the noise is definitely the diff , probly bad pinion bearing
Not sure how the locker looks inside, if it is the diff could just be chatter, you ever lock it?
Your issue could also be the park brake shoes, mine did some weird stuff when the lining fell off drivers shoes so never know
We put it on a lift and ran in drive the noise is definitely the diff , probly bad pinion bearing
Not sure how the locker looks inside, if it is the diff could just be chatter, you ever lock it?
Your issue could also be the park brake shoes, mine did some weird stuff when the lining fell off drivers shoes so never know
#7
No way to manually lock the rear diff right? I've put the vehicle in off road situations and observed the rear diff lock via the display. Thats a good exersize though, I should give that a shot, couldn't hurt.
My gut tells me this is something much more obscure (like your e-brake pads) though, the symptoms seem way too random.
My gut tells me this is something much more obscure (like your e-brake pads) though, the symptoms seem way too random.
#9
I have the same issue.
About a year ago it was tougher to replicate; since then it has become easier. For me it happens in 4-Lo only, especially when it's loaded, like up a hill, steering input in...and the settings that are more "torquey" like Rock Crawl produce it more readily. I thought for sure it was the rear driveshaft.
Nope. It's the rear diff. My rear diff is only 3 years old, with ~20,000 miles! Grrrr....
...and mine is the locker, too. $$$
I'm going to replace that AND the rear driveshaft, the latter just for the hell of it.
Best of luck.
About a year ago it was tougher to replicate; since then it has become easier. For me it happens in 4-Lo only, especially when it's loaded, like up a hill, steering input in...and the settings that are more "torquey" like Rock Crawl produce it more readily. I thought for sure it was the rear driveshaft.
Nope. It's the rear diff. My rear diff is only 3 years old, with ~20,000 miles! Grrrr....
...and mine is the locker, too. $$$
I'm going to replace that AND the rear driveshaft, the latter just for the hell of it.
Best of luck.