Broken exhaust manifold bolts. It WILL happen to you!
So after a fun weekend of four wheeling in Utah, the last two times I have started the defender I am getting a metal rattle on a cold start. It lasts about 10 seconds. I am thinking this means I have some broken manifold bolts. Is there any other way to diagnose this problem other than taking apart a bunch of stuff?
Also would this possible lead to bad O2 sensors. I have replaced 3 in the last 9 months and now have a fourth that is needing to be replaced. Though this fourth one is one I replaced last year. I have about 60k miles on the defender.
Also would this possible lead to bad O2 sensors. I have replaced 3 in the last 9 months and now have a fourth that is needing to be replaced. Though this fourth one is one I replaced last year. I have about 60k miles on the defender.
@Saltek Motorsports Did you have to remove the exhaust manifold to get access to the broken studs?
If you did remove them, did you have any problem extracting unbroken bolts?
How much work is needed to be able to inspect for broken bolts?Would the use of a $99 endoscope make this task easier/trivial?
If you did remove them, did you have any problem extracting unbroken bolts?
How much work is needed to be able to inspect for broken bolts?Would the use of a $99 endoscope make this task easier/trivial?
take a trip so southern California. I'll take care of it for you 🙂
I saw the butchery on Kraken Defender courtesy of his dealer. Man they did a number on it.
For the moment I'm employing the head in the sand approach. If (and this is a big if) it's only one or two bolts that have snapped off, I may have plenty of happy miles before
If @Adamalli is right it's amazing to think LR have been passing this off as a dodgy O2 sensor for years. The cost of a recall on these would be astronomical.
But one day, and perhaps that day may never come, I may call on you to
Last edited by GavinC; Apr 1, 2026 at 04:22 PM.
Unfortunately no other way. The manifold is surrounded by heatshields. In fact the gasket has a heat shield integrated into it. More than likely the o2 sensor fault is for biased lean. If that's the case, its not your o2 sensor. Its the extra oxygen your manifold is sucking in and getting picked up by the sensor. Land rover sent out an ota update to address the biased lean o2 sensor fault. I feel it was just a bandaid fix to get people out of their warranty period. They knew about the broken exhaust bolts.
Well now I am going to call a local independent repair shop to get a quote on how much it is going to be to fix this problem. I will keep my receipt so when the enviable lawsuit happens I have a record and can maybe get some of my money back.
Last edited by Adamalli; Apr 1, 2026 at 06:29 PM.
Thx
@Saltek Motorsports Do you know if there has been any TSBs or other JLR documents talking about the problem. My local indie service provider has no clue about this and wants to do a lots of other non free diagnostic tests first. Basically he does not believe this is the problem.
@Saltek Motorsports Do you know if there has been any TSBs or other JLR documents talking about the problem. My local indie service provider has no clue about this and wants to do a lots of other non free diagnostic tests first. Basically he does not believe this is the problem.
Last edited by nashvegas; Apr 1, 2026 at 07:06 PM.
Try dropping / removing your front engine under skid plate (the big metal piece that says DEFENDER on it). When I did so (to change front differential oil), a broken bolt fell down. That’s similar to how @GavinC diagnosed his - a bolt was jammed in between the edge and empty space and he saw the threads sticking out on his. The bolts are unique looking and only used in that one place.


