Discovery II Talk about the Land Rover Discovery II within.
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

General Disco RANT

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
  #21  
Old 12-20-2016 | 09:58 AM
Fast951's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Rock Crawling
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 416
Likes: 41
From: Berks County, PA
Default

Originally Posted by dr. mordo
I have to agree. I've broken more bolts on this truck than every other vehicle I've worked on combined. And I was a professional mechanic for a couple of years.

I describe them as a "steel and butter alloy".
Yep. Like the non-graded bolts on the frame cross member support bars. With 10mm heads. Ridiculous.
 
  #22  
Old 12-20-2016 | 10:20 AM
Fast951's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Rock Crawling
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 416
Likes: 41
From: Berks County, PA
Default

Originally Posted by Best4x4
Bolts can wear out (threads can strip), and they can corrode from the elements/environment. That's what I was talking about. In your case it's due to an aluminum housing and steel bolt seizing it up.
A dab of Never-Seez from the factory would have worked wonders in this regard since LR was using non-graded bolts.

The AC draining onto the XYZ is the least of it's worries. The bolt is metal and the transmission housing is aluminum. Doesn't matter if it's the space shuttle or a Land Rover the metal and aluminum are going to constantly contract/expand upon heating up and cooling down and over time the bolt can seize into place.
Water dripping constantly on this bolt when the A/C is on what ensures the corrosion in this case. That spot on the end of the transmission doesn't really get all that hot. The bolt on the other end of the XYZ switch (where the water does not drip) came right out easily and without the use of penetrating oil. I loosened it with a 1/4" 10mm and removed it with my fingers.

The Radiator IS NOT hard to remove if you simply remove the front grill to gain access to the screws holding the securing plates over the radiator supports and on an 03-04 that is a 15-20 second job!
Of course you remove the front grille but the way LR mounted the radiator is still stupid. Not really up for debate.

We've all been there with a simple job that suddenly turns into a nightmare, but I take a step back, cool down, then go over the situation again and 99% of the time I come back with a simple and quick solution and I always learn from my mistakes.
Not to be argumentative, but I didn't make any mistakes in this circumstance. But yes, sometimes simple jobs turn into nightmares. Thank you LR.
 
  #23  
Old 12-20-2016 | 11:20 AM
Best4x4's Avatar
Super Moderator
Joined: Apr 2015
Posts: 7,742
Likes: 2,310
From: Beaumont, TX
Default

Once again I am sorry for your situation, but blaming LR for every little thing from incorrect bolts, lack of anti-seize, and poor quality/design on a 13 year old vehicle isn't really relevant. It made it 13 years before the XYZ switch died! Maybe a Toyota 4Runner would be a better for you.

All of my LR's have been either from CA or TX so I have ZERO rust or corrosion issues. Not sure how it is up in PA, but that could have a lot to do with it.

The radiator on a RRC/D1/D2 is mounted in a fashion like 90% of all the vehicles on the road today. The D2 radiator is a 1hr job if that.

If you want a radiator to complain about then look no further than a 99-04 Jeep Grand Cherokee with a 4.7L V8. On earlier models 99 the entire bumper/grill was one piece and had to be removed along with the headlights, fog lights, and the inner fender splash guards. Then you had a hydraulic controlled cooling fan that had to be completely removed and disconnected. After that you had little mounts all over the place supporting the radiator, and finally as per Jeep you had to evac your AC System, disconnect the condenser, and remove it before you could remove the radiator. A LR D2 is removing a fan shroud, grill, fan clutch, move an oil cooler/transmission cooler, and some mounts that secure the radiator into place........

I understand your upset with your D2 and it's apparent lack of quality, and reliability, and honestly once someone gets that kind of attitude about a vehicle you're better off selling it and moving on IMHO. There is no such thing as a perfect vehicle. Look at all the recalls today from airbags (Honda, Toyota, Chevy, Ford, and many more), fires (2012-2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee's/Dodge Durango's), wide open throttles (2016 Ford Explorer), blown motors with less than 1k on them (2016 Honda Civic's), and those are all on much newer vehicles.

I still say lift the carpet, drill a hole in the floor, drill out the broken bolt, apply your anti-seize, mount the XYZ Switch and call it a day for another 13 years. If the bolt didn't break off 100% flush with the transmission I'd just install it with the one screw and call it a day as one bolt with the little peg of the other broken bolt would keep it from moving. Or go all out, smash the transmission to bits to relieve some stress with a 25LB Sledge Hammer, and slap in a 200-400 03-04 D2 Transmission with everything and call it a day.
 

Last edited by Best4x4; 12-20-2016 at 11:30 AM.
  #24  
Old 12-20-2016 | 11:47 AM
Motorhead1's Avatar
Recovery Vehicle
Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 962
Likes: 87
From: Southern OR
Default

True stuff Best4x4....
I seen a ton of rusty D2's on this site, I would pass on one too. Too bad we still have a rust belt in this country....
Time to sell the ol' D2 Fast951...It's obvious your over it. We've all been in your situation one time or another on different vehicles, so we all understand, mechanic work can be like that...Good luck on your next adventure
 
  #25  
Old 12-20-2016 | 11:53 AM
Fast951's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Rock Crawling
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 416
Likes: 41
From: Berks County, PA
Default

Originally Posted by Best4x4
Once again I am sorry for your situation, but blaming LR for every little thing from incorrect bolts, lack of anti-seize, and poor quality/design on a 13 year old vehicle isn't really relevant. It made it 13 years before the XYZ switch died! Maybe a Toyota 4Runner would be a better for you.

All of my LR's have been either from CA or TX so I have ZERO rust or corrosion issues. Not sure how it is up in PA, but that could have a lot to do with it.

The radiator on a RRC/D1/D2 is mounted in a fashion like 90% of all the vehicles on the road today. The D2 radiator is a 1hr job if that.

If you want a radiator to complain about then look no further than a 99-04 Jeep Grand Cherokee with a 4.7L V8. On earlier models 99 the entire bumper/grill was one piece and had to be removed along with the headlights, fog lights, and the inner fender splash guards. Then you had a hydraulic controlled cooling fan that had to be completely removed and disconnected. After that you had little mounts all over the place supporting the radiator, and finally as per Jeep you had to evac your AC System, disconnect the condenser, and remove it before you could remove the radiator. A LR D2 is removing a fan shroud, grill, fan clutch, move an oil cooler/transmission cooler, and some mounts that secure the radiator into place........

I understand your upset with your D2 and it's apparent lack of quality, and reliability, and honestly once someone gets that kind of attitude about a vehicle you're better off selling it and moving on IMHO. There is no such thing as a perfect vehicle. Look at all the recalls today from airbags (Honda, Toyota, Chevy, Ford, and many more), fires (2012-2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee's/Dodge Durango's), wide open throttles (2016 Ford Explorer), blown motors with less than 1k on them (2016 Honda Civic's), and those are all on much newer vehicles.

I still say lift the carpet, drill a hole in the floor, drill out the broken bolt, apply your anti-seize, mount the XYZ Switch and call it a day for another 13 years. If the bolt didn't break off 100% flush with the transmission I'd just install it with the one screw and call it a day as one bolt with the little peg of the other broken bolt would keep it from moving. Or go all out, smash the transmission to bits to relieve some stress with a 25LB Sledge Hammer, and slap in a 200-400 03-04 D2 Transmission with everything and call it a day.
Sure. I'm just a little peeved at the prospect of removing the tranny after I JUST installed a new P38 engine and it's now 17 degrees here in PA. Plus, I need the vehicle for the bad weather and there it is again in the ******* garage in my wife's space on jackstands. So thanks, and I do appreciate your posts, but I'm just not in the mood for comparison to other crappy vehicles or the defense of Land Rover right now.
 
  #26  
Old 12-20-2016 | 11:55 AM
Fast951's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Rock Crawling
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 416
Likes: 41
From: Berks County, PA
Default

Originally Posted by Motorhead1
True stuff Best4x4....
I seen a ton of rusty D2's on this site, I would pass on one too. Too bad we still have a rust belt in this country....
Time to sell the ol' D2 Fast951...It's obvious your over it. We've all been in your situation one time or another on different vehicles, so we all understand, mechanic work can be like that...Good luck on your next adventure
To be clear my D2 is rust free except where the blockheads at LR let the A/C discharge drip on my steel XYZ bolt screwed into aluminum with no anti-seize applied from the factory. Jeez!
 
  #27  
Old 12-20-2016 | 11:55 AM
Motorhead1's Avatar
Recovery Vehicle
Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 962
Likes: 87
From: Southern OR
Default

Oh man! I didn't know that...a new motor just replaced too....I'd be totally pee'd too. Sorry
 
  #28  
Old 12-20-2016 | 12:02 PM
Fast951's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Rock Crawling
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 416
Likes: 41
From: Berks County, PA
Default

Originally Posted by Motorhead1
Oh man! I didn't know that...a new motor just replaced too....I'd be totally pee'd too. Sorry
Yep. And I mean a new P38, not just new to me. NEW.

 
  #29  
Old 12-20-2016 | 12:06 PM
Best4x4's Avatar
Super Moderator
Joined: Apr 2015
Posts: 7,742
Likes: 2,310
From: Beaumont, TX
Default

Look into drilling the hole thru the floor first vs a transmission drop. It looked possible when I ran outside to inspect the space down there. You can get floor drain plugs normally on the HELP isle at the auto parts store.

In that cold of weather on the garage floor, I think a 30.00 sleeping bag would be a good investment. Just get a mummy one, cut some holes in it for your arms to hang out, and go to work.

Good luck and report back with how it goes.
 
  #30  
Old 12-20-2016 | 12:14 PM
Motorhead1's Avatar
Recovery Vehicle
Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 962
Likes: 87
From: Southern OR
Default

Originally Posted by Fast951
Yep. And I mean a new P38, not just new to me. NEW.

Damn, that's fancy. The sleeping bag idea might work? ha
 


Quick Reply: General Disco RANT



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:57 PM.