The X5 rim works for sure; I have a spare mounted on it. I don't know if the offset is quite right though, it's just a "get me home" spare and other than the initial test fit I've never mounted it. Pretty sure the offset was either the same or very close. I bought the thing about 10 years ago because it was easier to source than LR 18s at the time. If I were looking for a full set of rims I'd be patient and find the LR rims. My $0.02.