2003 Discovery Knocking!!
#21
come on ....
Come on guy's.. I think all senior members should be guilty of not saying it like it is..... The LR motors in the RR, Disco 4.0 and 4.6 NAS are the biggest pieces of f$cking **** know to this planet...For a so called prestigious car company to pin their name on this motor...well they should have been shot... A bunch of f$cking *** clowns...In all the 40 years of car and truck ownership ..This has been the biggest piece of sh$t I have ever owned..
If you plan on owning a Disco ...you should know from the get go it's going to ball up and go in flames... assume that and you will be ok..
Chris
If you plan on owning a Disco ...you should know from the get go it's going to ball up and go in flames... assume that and you will be ok..
Chris
#22
I don't know, I see plenty of other cars and trucks in the junk yard, lots of Jeeps, some look so nice you wonder why they were scrapped at 170K... lots of things don't do well without routine maintenance. Rover selected an engine from an era when 50,000 miles was the lifetime of a car, people traded in every 2 - 3 years. That same engine was 180F stat in the early 60's, no one back then ran an aluminum head engine over 200F. Enter the pollution control departments, and we have to run at the bleeding edge. Keep boring out the cylinders for more power and torque and the engine "meat" gets thinner, heat problems go up. GM has made plenty of engine designs since then. One was in the Vega....
But high dollar vehicles have prestige, and plenty of couples get one or two to go with that new 4500 square foot home on a culdesac. And they lease the cars. And the stork flies over a couple of times. ARM jumps up to Jupiter. And the corporate ladder climbing owner is soon having to cut back on things. Enter to 25,000 mile oil change. Right before lease turn in. Happens with Mercedes, BMWs, Lexus, Audi, and on and on. We are not alone in the "these expensive cars are a POS" department.
BMW sludge, anyone?
But high dollar vehicles have prestige, and plenty of couples get one or two to go with that new 4500 square foot home on a culdesac. And they lease the cars. And the stork flies over a couple of times. ARM jumps up to Jupiter. And the corporate ladder climbing owner is soon having to cut back on things. Enter to 25,000 mile oil change. Right before lease turn in. Happens with Mercedes, BMWs, Lexus, Audi, and on and on. We are not alone in the "these expensive cars are a POS" department.
BMW sludge, anyone?
Last edited by Savannah Buzz; 04-29-2012 at 09:52 PM.
#23
Discovery 2 td5
OK! I know everyone is going to remind me that this issue has been discussed a million times before, but nobody seems to have the definitive answer. I’ve heard everything from impending oil pump failure to the metal sleeve around the cylinders are shifting.
I’ve got a 2003 Discovery with 120,000 miles (Not in the oil pump VIN # death range!), and it has developed a metallic knocking sound at idle, only at operating temperature. Extremely loud at times! There are no other signs of engine failure (overheating, tailpipe smoke, consuming oil/coolant). I went to my land rover mechanic and he said that I should just live with it. He said that you can spend thousands of dollars trying to find the source of the knocking. As long as it doesn’t get worse, it should be fine.
I guess my question to you all is, am I living on borrowed time here (Oil Pump failure), or should I just drive like I own a diesel engine??
Thanks!
Josh
I’ve got a 2003 Discovery with 120,000 miles (Not in the oil pump VIN # death range!), and it has developed a metallic knocking sound at idle, only at operating temperature. Extremely loud at times! There are no other signs of engine failure (overheating, tailpipe smoke, consuming oil/coolant). I went to my land rover mechanic and he said that I should just live with it. He said that you can spend thousands of dollars trying to find the source of the knocking. As long as it doesn’t get worse, it should be fine.
I guess my question to you all is, am I living on borrowed time here (Oil Pump failure), or should I just drive like I own a diesel engine??
Thanks!
Josh
#24
And take a look at this solution write up https://landroverforums.com/forum/ge...ghlight=liners
Wonder at what temperature the ticking begins? 160? 180? 190? 210?
Wonder at what temperature the ticking begins? 160? 180? 190? 210?
#25
What year model? if pre 2003, get an inline thermostat and a 170 degree thermostat, if 2003 or later get a 180 degree thermostat for the inline. The inline is more reliable and cooler than the factory Disco stats so it will keep it out of the tick range and keep the HG in good shape.
#26
What year model? if pre 2003, get an inline thermostat and a 170 degree thermostat, if 2003 or later get a 180 degree thermostat for the inline. The inline is more reliable and cooler than the factory Disco stats so it will keep it out of the tick range and keep the HG in good shape.
i would prefer a 170 thermostat in it myself
#28
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post