A Pillar Flapping / Crackling noise at speed
#11
@mgreenawald Thank you for sharing that picture. Was always interested what it looked like under the covers. What color is your Defender? Guessing either black or gondwana. I have yet to see a black one in person, but was my first choice. Bought what was on the dealer lot being Gondwana stone.
Last edited by njdefendernj; 08-10-2020 at 02:26 PM.
#12
The following users liked this post:
njdefendernj (08-10-2020)
#14
nj - I have a black with black package. Interestingly, there I have seen one nearly identical around town. I had to drive about 500 miles to get mine out of market; got lucky as someone cancelled an order.
Update on the A-Pillar - took it into LR dealer today, they are ordering parts and replacing. They didn't mention a service bulletin but I will bring it up when the parts come in. My LR dealership is not friendly; (I have/had 5 LRs - 3 currently - in the family not one purchased from them, probably why they don't like me). I would think they would like my service revenue but oh well. I am not sure I will get much out of them when I bring up the service bulletin. I would post pictures of the other 2 parts that are on top but they kept the pieces - not sure if they are sending into LR.
Update on the A-Pillar - took it into LR dealer today, they are ordering parts and replacing. They didn't mention a service bulletin but I will bring it up when the parts come in. My LR dealership is not friendly; (I have/had 5 LRs - 3 currently - in the family not one purchased from them, probably why they don't like me). I would think they would like my service revenue but oh well. I am not sure I will get much out of them when I bring up the service bulletin. I would post pictures of the other 2 parts that are on top but they kept the pieces - not sure if they are sending into LR.
The following users liked this post:
njdefendernj (08-10-2020)
#15
I have 4,561 miles on, and so far nothing has gone flying off. Hope I didn't just jinx myself. On my A-Pillar, I was driving 80+ mph for large portions of the drive, and I would say the sound was there only about 5% of the time. It's really hit or miss in my situation.
----------------------------------------------------------
2020 Defender 110 First Edition Indus Silver (Current)
2020 Discovery HSE Luxury Si6 Fuji White (Current)
2015 RRS Autobiography Fuji White (Former)
2011 RRS Supercharged Fuji White (Former)
2008 LR2 Fuji White (Former)
----------------------------------------------------------
2020 Defender 110 First Edition Indus Silver (Current)
2020 Discovery HSE Luxury Si6 Fuji White (Current)
2015 RRS Autobiography Fuji White (Former)
2011 RRS Supercharged Fuji White (Former)
2008 LR2 Fuji White (Former)
Wow, the FB group seems to have it going on. Makes sense with the nature of the noise that it would get worse and come off. I have just hit the 800 mile mark so going to assume that by 1500 miles it will fly off. @Corgi_Express What FB group is it... the public one or the private one named "All New Defenders Group?" Not crazy about sharing my personal name but for this issue willing to share my real name. I just reached out to JLR corporate because not happy about this situation. Was fine with until finding out this poses a serious safety hazard.
@mgreenawald Thank you for sharing that picture. Was always interested what it looked like under the covers. What color is your Defender? Guessing either black or gondwana. I have yet to see a black one in person, but was my first choice. Bought what was on the dealer lot being Gondwana stone.
@mgreenawald Thank you for sharing that picture. Was always interested what it looked like under the covers. What color is your Defender? Guessing either black or gondwana. I have yet to see a black one in person, but was my first choice. Bought what was on the dealer lot being Gondwana stone.
The following users liked this post:
njdefendernj (08-10-2020)
#16
I have it, too. I apparently I didn't drive fast enough during the pre-sale test drive for ti to happen but it did it on the interstate driving home. It's the passenger side rattle around the A-pillar any time there's wind buffeting the windshield. For a time I thought it might be the windshield flexing from the adhesive- I had a similar noise on another vehicle until it finally 'popped' then stopped. I had recently had the windshield replaced and the installer said it was a common noise caused by the glass flex until the adhesive fully sets. I was hoping that was the cause on the Defender and it would go away on its own over time...
I did try flexing and adjusting that A-pillar cover and the rubber strip that touches the glass to try and locate but no success...
I did try flexing and adjusting that A-pillar cover and the rubber strip that touches the glass to try and locate but no success...
The following users liked this post:
Tucker Woods (08-12-2020)
#17
My dealer found it, after I pushed them a little. They detached the pillar A cover (nut on the bottom - engine compartment open), slide the cover off, put in filler/padding up and down the pillar, slide the cover back on (it should be very tight, hard to slide on) and tighten back the nut. Fixed it like a charm. No noise, even at 85mph
The following users liked this post:
DefenderSmitty (12-20-2020)
#19
My dealer found it, after I pushed them a little. They detached the pillar A cover (nut on the bottom - engine compartment open), slide the cover off, put in filler/padding up and down the pillar, slide the cover back on (it should be very tight, hard to slide on) and tighten back the nut. Fixed it like a charm. No noise, even at 85mph
#20