2003 LR Disco II Transmission Fluid - partial replacement?
I don't know, I've changed trans fluid and filter a bunch of times on my Mercedes, and so has my buddy on at least 2 of his Benzes... They were all about 100k miles initially. So to me, changing the fluid (partial change every time) is a normal thing, however... There is no smoke without fire, so guess people have had that experience of failures after fluid replacement?
Another thing is - when I dumped fluid from the t-case, what came out was a dark stinking goo, and the truck started making far less noise and drove better after the fluid change. So trans fluid can and probably will degrade over time, no?
Another thing is - when I dumped fluid from the t-case, what came out was a dark stinking goo, and the truck started making far less noise and drove better after the fluid change. So trans fluid can and probably will degrade over time, no?
Here is the critical statement in your post... "I don't like the way the transmission has been acting the past couple of days."
I would first check fluid level. Maybe it's low. If it's low, top if off. Report back? See if that helps.
I hate to break it to you but a fluid change probably isn't going to fix whatever issue you're having (aside from low fluid level causing problems). So ... you can try changing it... but I would bet you're looking at a replacement transmission, whether or not you change the fluid. I have never once had a transmission fluid change on an old ZF box like these help the transmission when it was already having problems.
On a properly working trans, yes, a slight improvement in shifting and smoothness but that's about it. I've never once *ever* had a fluid change fix a problem that had already started. Basically what others said above.
I would first check fluid level. Maybe it's low. If it's low, top if off. Report back? See if that helps.
I hate to break it to you but a fluid change probably isn't going to fix whatever issue you're having (aside from low fluid level causing problems). So ... you can try changing it... but I would bet you're looking at a replacement transmission, whether or not you change the fluid. I have never once had a transmission fluid change on an old ZF box like these help the transmission when it was already having problems.
On a properly working trans, yes, a slight improvement in shifting and smoothness but that's about it. I've never once *ever* had a fluid change fix a problem that had already started. Basically what others said above.
Here is the critical statement in your post... "I don't like the way the transmission has been acting the past couple of days."
I would first check fluid level. Maybe it's low. If it's low, top if off. Report back? See if that helps.
I hate to break it to you but a fluid change probably isn't going to fix whatever issue you're having (aside from low fluid level causing problems). So ... you can try changing it... but I would bet you're looking at a replacement transmission, whether or not you change the fluid. I have never once had a transmission fluid change on an old ZF box like these help the transmission when it was already having problems.
On a properly working trans, yes, a slight improvement in shifting and smoothness but that's about it. I've never once *ever* had a fluid change fix a problem that had already started. Basically what others said above.
I would first check fluid level. Maybe it's low. If it's low, top if off. Report back? See if that helps.
I hate to break it to you but a fluid change probably isn't going to fix whatever issue you're having (aside from low fluid level causing problems). So ... you can try changing it... but I would bet you're looking at a replacement transmission, whether or not you change the fluid. I have never once had a transmission fluid change on an old ZF box like these help the transmission when it was already having problems.
On a properly working trans, yes, a slight improvement in shifting and smoothness but that's about it. I've never once *ever* had a fluid change fix a problem that had already started. Basically what others said above.
Having said that, I guess, I am supposed to check tranny level with the engine running but with the tranny barely worm, not hot? Which means I can't drive the truck to a work location and check the fluid unless it cools off. And it would take hours for it to cool off... Do I understand this correctly? I am confused.
@MyOldCars Hot or cold should not make too much of a difference,the engine is running so the pump is circulating fluid. If your truck sits for a couple hours you would be fine.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



