Baldwin hands down.

 

How many oil filters in a case? 12? 24?
For the average person who drives a average of 12,000 miles a year and changes their oil every 3,000 miles 12 oil filters will last 3 years.
Most American's drive 12,000 miles a year, most change their oil every 4-5,000 miles.
Most get a "new" car every 3-5 years.
Most dont buy the exact same car again, whats the point of getting a new car if you're going to buy the exact same one?
So whats the point of having a case of oil filters sitting on the shelf in your garage?
Oil filter technology changes all the time, why wouldn't you want the newest filter?
If you are running track days and need to change your oil every weekend or you own a fleet of vans all with the same engine thats different.
But, like I said, for the average DIY'er its a waste to have your money tied up in oil filter inventory in your garage.
Here is one example, a guy on here had a DII, he bought a case of oil filters for his truck, a year later it was totaled in a accident, he then bought a Jetta.
He was then stuck with a case of oil filters he could not use, $50 wasted.
Thats half a tank of gas.

 

You guys get these filters pretty cheap here in Canada Canadian tire has the Mobil 301 for 16 bucks.