2020 Defender Talk about the new 2020 Land Rover Defender
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

Grenadier Experience and measurements to L663

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Jun 2, 2023 | 08:45 PM
  #241  
_Allegedly's Avatar
Pro Wrench
Joined: Jun 2021
Posts: 1,558
Likes: 1,439
Default

[QUOTE=EchorecT7E;867097If you have a look at the Bronco6G forum, there is a Ford rep on there ensuring everyone is taken care of.
[/QUOTE]

Having owned a Bronco that showed up 3 months late at the dealership with an airbag light on, GOaT modes not functional, a bad fuse box, a leak, missing trim parts, and a few other random problems, I got absolutely nowhere in the 6G forum. My dealership was amazing but Ford did not give a fuch. That's all blowing smoke.
 
Reply
Old Jun 2, 2023 | 08:47 PM
  #242  
EchorecT7E's Avatar
Mudding
Joined: Nov 2022
Posts: 174
Likes: 50
Default

Originally Posted by GavinC
My 1300 mile old Alternator **** the bed. I was not a happy camper. Quite the inauguration into LR ownership.



As others have mentioned.

It's more expensive than I anticipated by a lot
It's more expensive than my P400 SE which has rear locker and all the off-road chops
It does not appear that is as billed, a cheap to mod platform
It's wading depth is worse at a paltry 800mm
It does not (as I mistakenly thought at time of ordering) have a factory snorkel. RAIs can **** right off.
It has inferior departure, approach and break-over angles to my Defender

I think it looks great. I love that it comes with factory lockers and sliders. The winch too but that's a lot pricier than anticipated.
I love that it comes on 17" rims albeit with tires that are too small. Less than 32" on the 17" rim. 32" on the 18" rim
I would have a lot of fun with one.

I'm indifferent to live axle v IFS/IRS
I've hd no problems with my air suspension. very useful for me. I couldn't fit a Grenadier in my garage with ski-rack AFAIK
I do like the simple approach when it comes to mirrors and suspension components though.

I think buyers will be very happy with their Grenadiers. I'll not be among them unfortunately (or fortunately)
I hope buyers are happy with their car, I don’t care who makes it. It totally sucks when something blows on a new vehicle (as we LR owners know more than anyone, lol).

I also hope the Gren is successful enough for a gen 2. There are many things I think could be addressed to make a far more polished and coherent offering. I am somewhat concerned as I I do not see this doing will in the US/Canada. As many have said, at its MSRP it is a terrible value proposition and no protection from dealership markup to top it off. F that.
 

Last edited by EchorecT7E; Jun 2, 2023 at 08:59 PM.
Reply
Old Jun 3, 2023 | 07:17 AM
  #243  
4Corsa's Avatar
Mudding
Joined: Oct 2020
Posts: 110
Likes: 85
Default

I suppose I’ll go on record and say that we’re ordering one. Actually two (because at this point I haven’t had to pay anything additional and can get a refund on our deposit). But since everyone has thrown out their thoughts and judgements on the Grenadier I figured I’d do the same.

Here’s my take on the Ineos - it’s a simplified, rugged, ‘overland built’ SUV that we can FINALLY buy here in the US vs watch everyone in Europe have fun with yet another automobile that we can’t get access to.the components that it’s comprised of are all top notch, and a sense it’s overbuilt for (perceived) reliability and longevity from the factory. Having driven one at one of the events near Atlanta, and spending a few hours afterwards crawling all over the thing most of my concerns were alleviated. The interior had just the right amount of spartan-ness for me, the plastics didn’t feel cheap (like a Jeep) and the seats were comfortable.

Speaking of seats - I may be in the minority but I’ve never been in love with my Defenders. I have an HSE with full leather and adjustability but to me they’re not very supportive and the seat base is flat. But then I prefer a heavily bolstered seat. My father had a GT3 with factory Cup Bucket seats that had zero adjustability and it was the most comfortable thing I’ve ever driven. It was like a gentle hug and caress as you careened around corners at 110mph (on the track so calm down).

I may fall in the minority too as I prefer switches for simple things. And the pre wired switches for external power is a pretty cool option that we don’t have for our Defenders without drilling through the roof. Dual battery setup from the factory ticks another box as I don’t have the skills, or more importantly the time to invest to install one in the Defender.

Regarding tires I can now choose between 17” or 18”. Now I don’t need to take a grinder to my calipers or swap them.

Then I come to the attempt to significantly reduce the number of computer systems in the build. Sure they have to include some things otherwise it would never be allowed for sale here, but you can’t argue that they’ve simplified as much as possible to meet that goal. Going as far as to only offer a mechanical functioning seat.

So with all this being said the Grenadier will replace my wife’s G550, which for all the talk around ‘bullet proof reliability’ has been a disappointment. To me the INEOS is like the commercial version of gate g-wagon that we can’t get here. Regarding where prices go once deliveries come in, reservation holders should hopefully be protected by any markup, which I won’t pay. They can control what dealers do but then no manufacture can hear in the US. The price is around where I’d anticipated, sure it would have been markedly less if we hadn’t just gone through the rapid inflation and supply problems of the last three years. Not sure if I’ll go through with the second Grenadier order, but I don’t have to decide or commit any more money at the moment. And I still really like my 2021 Defender, I just with I could get my replacement headlight to replace the one I have where the ‘signature running lights’ have failed. Fortunately still under warranty for a few more miles, but the thought of paying $4,000 for a replacement headlight just because it’s a sealed unit down the road is a little scary. I just with a car company would design something more simple and easier to work on long term….
 
Reply
Old Jun 6, 2023 | 02:53 PM
  #244  
curb-optional's Avatar
Rock Crawling
Joined: May 2023
Posts: 251
Likes: 95
From: USA
Default

Originally Posted by _Allegedly
Sure, the Grenadier will last longer by virtue of it not having 23 computers, a a mild-hybrid supercharger, an extra turbo, navigation, a dozen cameras, a hundred sensors, adaptive cruise control, a gauge cluster, power mirrors...

Recirculating ball steering will certainly last forever. Someone above thought this might be good because they're getting older and looking for a "last car" or something - as long as you don't plan to turn much once the arthritis sets in.

Idk, I'm too spoiled by modernity. I had to admit I don't want a new old truck that probably drives like a Home Depot rental once you get above 75.

The Grenadier will last longer. Eating a paper towel would also last longer than eating some duck fat fries.

I don't want 13 mpg ever again unless it's in my boat.

If I mention my wife's Taycan EV that gets 240 miles of range, I'd get crucified with "that sucks, you're a moron for putting up with such limited range". But somehow it's okay for a truck to get 240 miles on a tank? No. F that. The Taycan charges at home every few days while we sleep. Have only charged twice on the road for 15 minutes each. Does anyone actually like to stop and get gas?

The Grenadier is an axe. Chopping wood is fun when you go camping. It would completely suck if it was a daily chore.
Ah! well this is a stumbling block for some but not everyone: the daily drive. I drive a 2015 LR, drives wonderfully. I think Grenadier is positioned to attract the Bronco/Wrangler crowd, as I can not see this first version as an alternative for the 110 Defender. Although Grenadier seems indestructible under light artillery fire, the family use SUV has to keep the entire family happy & comfortable. Heated back seats, quiet cabin, places for cups, phone charging, the whole thing. Nobody wants an uncomfortable or cramped 4 hour drive as part of a family trip. To be fair to Grenadier, I don't think I was on Ineos radar in the 1st round of production. I test drove a LC once, wonderful drive and lots of comfortable (but not luxurious) space. If Grenadier future models target more the old LC, I'd be interested again. The LC looked big, but it drove fairly easily - nice on-road manners, plus it had all the stuff you'd want for the interior. It seemed perfect, and now that Toyota no longer sells LC, maybe Ineos can try for some of those buyers in the future?
 
Reply
Old Jun 23, 2023 | 04:18 PM
  #245  
curb-optional's Avatar
Rock Crawling
Joined: May 2023
Posts: 251
Likes: 95
From: USA
Default

Originally Posted by NoGaBiker
Yeah, it's crazy. Both are 3 liter Inline Turbocharged sixes. P400 makes 395/405. Grenadier makes 281/332. So it's not like they tuned it for big torque at the expense of some ponies. It gives up 114 hp AND 73 torx. How do you even do that? 1998 called and wants its turbo I6 back. Heck, my wife's little GLC300 Benz gets 255/295 out of a 2.0 four.
although both engines are a 6, the Defender has some electric help - I'm not sure how, but they call it a "mild hybrid" and I'm figuring it's not an apples to apples comparison because the Defender has that extra power from (I'm assuming) some hybrid batter tucked in there. I find that to be tremendously ingenious of LR, as why not give a bit extra power to the gas engine with some electrons?!
 
Reply
Old Jul 18, 2023 | 03:44 AM
  #246  
lightning's Avatar
Winching
Joined: Jan 2023
Posts: 599
Likes: 317
Default

The main issue with the Grenadier is the price, with the most recent price hike the cheapest two seat Grenadier is now £65,000 ($85,000)

Add a few essential options such as a tow bar and it's £70,000 ($91,500)

The new Defender starts at £51,500 ($67,500)
With the tow bar and a few options it's £55,000 ($71,000)

Although the Grenadier is still cheaper than a Mercedes G-Wagon
 

Last edited by lightning; Jul 18, 2023 at 03:55 AM.
Reply
Old Jul 28, 2023 | 10:43 AM
  #247  
ADVAW8S's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Rock Crawling
Joined: Jul 2020
Posts: 420
Likes: 272
From: Kirkland
Default

As promised, I would keep adding information as time goes on. Here is a recent video from car journalist Robert Pepper. He borrowed a friend's Grenadier and put it through the paces against a LR2 and his Nissan Patrol. Both are older vehicles and he has indicated he is trying to put a test together with the L663 and new Ford Everest. He is very honest and points out some important issues with the Grenadier off road. @TrioLRowner I think you orginal comments are spot on.

 
Reply
Old Aug 16, 2023 | 05:55 PM
  #248  
curb-optional's Avatar
Rock Crawling
Joined: May 2023
Posts: 251
Likes: 95
From: USA
Default

Looks like Ineos bought a company in Africa called Kavango. Compared to JLR (which is going more toward suburban mall shoppers), the Grenadier - as aggressive as it was at the outset - seems to be continuing the trend of finding a way to build a durable off roader. You have to hand it to them - they are clearly going all in on making an SUV that will take whatever happens on along your drive.


 
Reply
Old Aug 16, 2023 | 06:21 PM
  #249  
GavinC's Avatar
TReK
Joined: May 2021
Posts: 2,565
Likes: 3,633
From: Kirkland WA
Default

The safari Grenadiers really look the part. Top notch vision. These shots are from Botswana despite the German rego.

It was all Landcruisers when I was kicking about the wilds of Botswana, Zim and SA many moons ago.

It is sad to say but I don't think JLR want any piece of that sort of market anymore. Can't very well chop a monocoque too easily to make this happen with a new Defender.

The arrival of the revamped 2024/5 Landcruiser however, including a new 70 series in Australia and Africa, will really put the squeeze on this side of their market I think.

A cheap(er) easy to mod live-axled, body-on-frame, coil-sprung platform with a sound reputation.
 
Reply
Old Aug 16, 2023 | 07:42 PM
  #250  
ADVAW8S's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Rock Crawling
Joined: Jul 2020
Posts: 420
Likes: 272
From: Kirkland
Default

I think Sir Ratcliffe is going for jugular in the safari space with this move. He can make the vehicle super cheap. Think about it just center lock, none of the creature comforts and the design lends itself to a 7 seater. They already have proof of concept and first to market. The design has already been put on sale to African Safari to pre-order. That is a head start. Tough for Land Cruiser to jump on board if no one is looking because they already bought it.
 
Reply



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:43 PM.