Different Head Gasket issue
Had an indie mechanic look at replacing the crank speed sensor. He said coolant was dripping on it and that it meant an HG replacement. There's no coolant in the crankcase, no smoke, temp is right between the goalposts but there is definitely a small coolant leak.
Question: If this is an HG problem, it certainly seems like no cylinder is compromised. I'm not getting misfires or any of the other "gaskety" symptoms. The crank speed sensor is down by the crank (naturally) and it seems that the coolant would have to follow a pretty twisty path to get there from a gasket leak, although it's clearly not outside the realm of possibility. The coolant loss is pretty slow.
I've checked most of the threads and haven't seen this type of leak. The DII has 120K on it which puts it in HG replacement range, but it seems unusual to me and I was wondering if anyone had experience with this or if it could be something else that wouldn't take a week of evenings or $2500 to fix.
I truly love this forum. Don't know what I'd do without it.
Question: If this is an HG problem, it certainly seems like no cylinder is compromised. I'm not getting misfires or any of the other "gaskety" symptoms. The crank speed sensor is down by the crank (naturally) and it seems that the coolant would have to follow a pretty twisty path to get there from a gasket leak, although it's clearly not outside the realm of possibility. The coolant loss is pretty slow.
I've checked most of the threads and haven't seen this type of leak. The DII has 120K on it which puts it in HG replacement range, but it seems unusual to me and I was wondering if anyone had experience with this or if it could be something else that wouldn't take a week of evenings or $2500 to fix.
I truly love this forum. Don't know what I'd do without it.
Thanks all. I'll ask the shop if the pressure-tested the system to verify the leak. I can still return the vehicle, since it's within 30 days and this is Massachusetts. Hoping to keep it, since most everything else (except the usual LR issues) is great. Body & interior are perfect. If the dealer will spring for the HG replacement, I'm good to go. Will pull timing cover, clean throttle body and other stuff at the same time.
Massachusetts lemon laws also has mileage limitations and I think they end at 100k, unless it does not pass inspection.
I mean even in a state as liberal as Mass. you can expect someone to warranty a car that has a million miles on it for 30-days.
I mean even in a state as liberal as Mass. you can expect someone to warranty a car that has a million miles on it for 30-days.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
mike111
Discovery II
28
Jun 2, 2014 08:58 AM



